| 2004/05 Season | Player of the Year | Danny Walsh |
| Players Player of the Year | Mark Jukes | |
| Golden Boot | Neil Roskilly | |
| Goal of the Season | Ben Wallace | |
| 2003/04 Season | Player of the Year | Dean Seaton |
| Players Player of the Year | Dean Seaton | |
| Golden Boot | Ian Robinson | |
| 2002/03 Season | Player of the Year | Neil Marking |
| Players Player of the Year | Dean Seaton | |
| Golden Boot | Sean Clem | |
| 2001/02 Season | Player of the Year | Richard Wilson |
| Players Player of the Year | Lee Maloney | |
| Golden Boot | Sean Clem | |
| Goal of the Season | Jim McGarry | |
| Clubman of the Year | Steven Holmes | |
| 2000/01 Season | Player of the Year | Sean Clem |
| Players Player of the Year | Dean Seaton | |
| Golden Boot | Paul Howard | |
| Goal of the Season | Andy Clem | |
| Most Improved Player | Adam Wallace | |
| Clubmen of the Year | Ben Wallace | |
| Neil Marking | ||
| 1999/00 Season | Player of the Year | Paul Howard |
| Players Player of the Year | Matt Wilson | |
| Golden Boot | Paul Howard | |
| Clubman of the Year | Ben Wallace |